Sarah Beth and I have decided to format our book reviews as book reports. Any MBHS-ers out there remember the horrendous book reports (I think she called them something more intimidating) that Mrs. Lawrence assigned in 10th grade English? Terrible. It’s funny that we’re now voluntarily engaging in such a task. Let us know what you think of the format , if you have any suggestions for additions to it, or if you’d like to create your own book report and guest post on Idaclare!
Title: All Over but the Shoutin’
Author: Rick Bragg
How I came to pick up this book: I read it as a young teen, after my parents read and loved it. In fact, my mom reminded me yesterday that she actually gave a book talk on Bragg’s memoir to our classes when we were in junior high school. But this year, I read Bragg’s story again because it was assigned for my Human Behavior class. After reading, we had to write a paper assessing the family dynamics evident in the text.
Basic scenario: Bragg, an awarded journalist for The New York Times and other publications, writes the story of his life–including his father’s abandonment, his mother’s strength, his family’s struggle in the midst of poverty, and the culture of the small Alabama town in which he grew up.
Favorite Quote: “The first memory I have is of a tall blond woman who drags a canvas cotton sack along an undulating row of rust-colored ground, through a field that seems to reach into the back forty of forever…it is the memory of that woman, that boy and that vast field that continues to ride and ride in my mind, not only because it is a warm, safe and proud thing I carry with me like a talisman into cold, dangerous and spirit-numbing places, but beacuse it so perfectly sums up the way she carried us, with such dignity.” -from Chapter 3
Strengths: Bragg’s memoir is a moving reminder of the beauty wrapped up in a person’s story. His use of language and description is phenomenal. He paints pictures, often using repetition, imagery, and figurative language, that are realistic and moving. He seems to effortlessly weave in humor among the poignant themes of his life. He portrays the South and the people who lived there during the 60s with complexity, recognizing difficult truths of his heritage but refusing to stereotype when it would be easy to do so. He questions himself–his motives, desires, and thoughts–when it seems appropriate. His honesty makes his character and story relevant to the common human struggle of finding meaning and redemption in the difficult events of the past.
Weaknesses: It was difficult for me to pinpoint any weaknesses in the text. One that comes to mind is my difficulty in remembering the characters of Bragg’s extended family, who play minor roles in the memoir. This difficulty is very likely more related to my flawed short-term memory rather than Bragg’s writing style.
Where I found myself reading this book: In bed before sleep, on my sofa, and on my front porch, all the while my dog laying at my feet…as he is now.
*picture from borders.com